Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Instagram
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Books
  • Retreats
  • Interviews
  • Resources
  • Reflections
  • Other Resources
  • Donate
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
Product was added to your cart

Cart

FAST FOOD: Twenty-Third Helping

July 23, 2013adminBlog – Fast Food 2013

The motto of the great ones might well be “Winner Take All—Even the Memories.” The winner owns history and bends it to his will.
-Daniel Berrigan, S.J., The Kings and Their gods

Mrs. Rooney lived down the street from me in the 1940s when I was a little kid. The street was a small dirt road going between two moderately used paved roads. For the most part it was only driven-on by the few residents who lived on it. Mrs. Rooney was in her eighties. Most of the day she sat at a first floor window of her home in a rocking chair and watched the children playing in the street. She also prayed the Rosary all day long, while looking out of the window. When asked for whom she did all that praying, she would say, “For the children playing out there.”

Now suppose, someone asked me, if I remember Mrs. Rooney. I would answer, “Yes, she was the old woman who sat at the window all day.” Would that be a historically accurate memory and a truthful answer? Yes. Would it be a historically complete memory? No. Would it be a memory that was leaving out a very important and well-known piece of her life at that time? Yes. If my questioner was trying to find out information about Mrs. Rooney’s religious belief or spiritual life or sense of compassion or spiritual consciousness would my brief response that “She was the old woman who sat at the window all day” be sufficient? No. If my questioner was trying to write a book, presenting models that others could be inspired by and imitate, on good and kind things anonymous people do would my “She was the old lady who sat in the window all day,” be of any significant psychological, emotional, cognitive or spiritual value to the author or to those he wished to help by his writing? No!

Mrs. Rooney and Jesus

Jesus does not merely “suffer and die,” as the texts say in most of the Eucharistic Prayers of most of the Churches. He does not die of a heart attack. Jesus is tortured and murdered. He dies when His heart is attacked by human beings inebriated with the diabolical spirit of justified, religiously endorsed homicide and enmity—and He dies giving a definite, discernible, and consistent response to that satanic spirit in action. The Gospel fact, of the Way He responded with love to even lethal evil, cannot be insignificant in discerning the Truth of the revelation God is trying to communicate to humanity for the good of humanity in Jesus. Yet, it is absent from nearly all Eucharistic Prayers.

The Sacrifice of the Cross is not about mere animal pain that is meant to assuage the lust of a sadistic, bloodthirsty, parochial god. It is about the revelation of the nature and meaning, Way and Power of Divine Love, a Love that saves from an Enemy and a menace that the darkest phenomena of history can only but hint at. The historically and theologically emaciated phraseology of “suffered and died” in Eucharistic Prayers, while not erroneous, is anemic revelatory remembrance (anamnesis).

There may be more to remembering Jesus in his passion and death at the Eucharist than the historical memory. But, there is no substitute for accurately and actually remembering the historical content of His passion and death—which is not just that He “suffered and died.” It must also include the Spirit in which He suffered and died: rejecting the use of violence, loving His enemies, returning good for evil, praying for His persecutors, and forgiving His torturers and murderers. This is Gospel fact, not spiritual conjecture. It is Gospel fact every bit as much as the Gospel fact that He was crucified.

To consistently ignore and to structurally bracket-out within the Eucharistic Prayer this major fact in the God-given revelatory memory, is to assure that little of what God intended to be communicated and accomplished by this costly revelation will be communicated and accomplished by it. To side-step this authentic Apostolic memory in order to get to a more profound or holy or deep spirituality of the Eucharist is sheer folly. One has to have the humility to accept and work with revelation as God offers it. If one does not want to prayerfully enter into revelation as presented by God, then one has no access to revelation, for who but God can author revelation?

So, while the mere use of the words “suffered” and “died” in the Eucharistic Prayer is not theologically inaccurate and does meet the letter of the law in fulfilling Jesus’ Eucharistic command, “Do this in memory of me,” it is pastorally shriveled revelatory remembrance (anamnesis). It has all the depth of truth and meaning and witness that there would be in describing Mrs. Rooney as merely “the old woman who sat at the window all day.”

The terrible pastoral danger of a mere skin and bones, “suffer and died Eucharistic Prayer,” with no serious communication of the Spirit in which Jesus suffered and died, is that it leaves the Eucharistic Prayer wide open to being transformed from an avenue of anamnesis to an agency for amnesia.

The struggle of man against power is the struggle of memory against forgetfulness. -Milan Kundera

-ECM

(To be continued)

Tags: christian nonviolence, Emmanuel Charles McCarthy, Fasting, Gospel nonviolence, Love your enemies, Nonviolent Jesus, Nonviolent Way
admin
Previous post FAST FOOD: Twenty-Second Helping Next post FAST FOOD: Twenty-Fourth Helping

Related Articles

RECLAIMING JESUS —BUT NOT— THE NONVIOLENT JESUS OF THE GOSPELS

June 18, 2018admin

2012 – Fast Food Third Helping

July 12, 2012admin

Serving those who serve us…military chaplaincy…collection for the military

May 12, 2014admin

Recent Posts

  • Fast Food 2024 1st Jul to 9th Aug (42nd Anniversary)
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Fortieth Helping
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Thirty-Ninth Helping
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Thirty-Eighth Helping
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Thirty-Seventh Helping

Recent Comments

  • admin on FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Fortieth Helping
  • admin on FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Fortieth Helping
  • Rodriggo on FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Fortieth Helping
  • admin on Fast Food 2022 1st Jul to 9th Aug (40th Anniversary)
  • Patrick on Fast Food 2022 1st Jul to 9th Aug (40th Anniversary)

Recent Posts

  • Fast Food 2024 1st Jul to 9th Aug (42nd Anniversary) July 2, 2024
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Fortieth Helping August 10, 2023
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Thirty-Ninth Helping August 8, 2023
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Thirty-Eighth Helping August 7, 2023
June 2025
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  
« Jul    

Tags

A Christian Response to Terrorism August 9 The Censer Behold the lamb capital punishment christian nonviolence christians in the military Christmas civil disobedience Collection for the Catholic Military Archdiocese Death electing a pope Emmanuel Charles charlie McCarthy Emmanuel Charles McCarthy emmanuel mccarthy fast food Fasting Gospel Gospel nonviolence jesus journal kingdom of the lamb Love your enemies Meaning Mercy Mercy:The essence of the Gospel Mercy and the Gospel military chaplain Nonviolence Nonviolent Jesus Nonviolent Mercy Nonviolent Way oath pope's final day pope benedict's resignation pope resigns pope resigns 2013 prayer prayer for peace Resurrection spanish swearing The Lamb Rich in Mercy vocations Vocations and prayer issues when a pope resigns zabelka

Categories

  • 'Special Topics (10)
  • Action Against Violence (13)
  • Audio Files (11)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2012 (42)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2014 (40)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2016 (42)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2018 (40)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2019 (40)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2020 (1)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2024 (1)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2013 (40)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2015 (40)
  • Booklets (11)
  • Books (5)
  • Edith Stein (6)
  • Fast Food Helpings (Previous) (199)
    • Blog – Fast Food 2022 (1)
  • Home (8)
  • Images of War (16)
  • Jesus Journal (8)
  • Other Resources (195)
    • Blog – Fast Food 2023 (40)
  • Retreats (3)
  • Special topics (64)
  • The Nonviolent Eucharist (5)
  • Transcripts (10)
  • Uncategorized (36)
  • Videos (17)
  • Vocations and Prayer Articles (26)

About Us

The full embracing of Gospel Nonviolence calls for a radical alteration in thought patterns, verbal patterns, behavioral patterns, and emotional patterns. That is, it requires a completely different reality orientation and self-understanding.

Quick Links

  • Faq’s
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Terms & Conditions

Contacts

8 Moneynoe Park Enniskillen , Co. Fermanagh Northern Ireland, BT74 4ER
Facebook
Vimeo
Behance
Instagram
Xing
SoundCloud
Copyright © 2021 All Rights Reserved by Fr. Emmanuel Charles McCarthy