Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Instagram
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Books
  • Retreats
  • Interviews
  • Resources
  • Reflections
  • Other Resources
  • Donate
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
Product was added to your cart

Cart

FAST FOOD (2018): Sixth Helping

August 10, 2018adminBlog - Fast Food 2018, Fast Food Helpings (Previous), Other Resources

FAST FOOD (2018): Sixth Helping

 

“No Christian theologian or writer prior to Constantine justified killing or Christian participation in the military.”

The Early Church on Killing

—Ronald J. Sider, PhD (History, Yale)

 

The Christian Just War Theory is rooted in two statements:

 

  1. God Incarnate, the Messiah, the Jesus of historical record, the Jesus of the Gospels was Nonviolent and taught a Way of Nonviolent Love of friends and enemies to His Apostles and disciple so that they could “love as He loves” and so they could teach those they Baptized “to obey all that I have commanded you.” And this they did for the three hundred years closest to Jesus’ Resurrection.

 

  1. “Nevertheless,” Christians can engage in the mass homicide of war.

 

Huh? Where does this “nevertheless” come from after three hundred years? No one even mentioned it during those first three hundred years. If Jesus wanted to make this a part of His salvific teaching and Way, why didn’t He? And, if those Christians who lived and died during those first three hundred years did not ever mention a “nevertheless” was it because they were unable to cognitively conceive a homicidal “nevertheless” alternative to Jesus’ teaching? Or was it because right-mindedness, truthfulness, uprightness of conscience and moral integrity would not allow them to replace the clear teaching of their Lord, God and Savior with a “nevertheless” that was a direct contradiction of the teaching of God “made flesh?” And of course, those first three centuries were times of brutal Roman persecution of Christians. There were at least three instances during that time that it became the policy of the Roman government to execute the ‘final solution’ to its “Christian problem” and liquidate the Christian community. Yet, in the face of lethal enmity and the seeming total destruction of Christian lives, loved ones and livelihoods, not a sentence was written by a Christian theologian or writer during that time justifying killing of lethal enemies who were unjustly massacring Christians and their families or anyone else.

 

One would think that if there was ever a time for the Church to introduce and justify a “nevertheless” to Jesus’ teachings of the rejection of violence and the love of enemies, this was certainly it! Natural law, justice, third party defense, duty to family, etc., were all available to prop-up a “nevertheless.” But, none of the old and well-known justifications for killing enemies was called into service to give Christian credence to a “nevertheless.” It did not happen—and it did not happen because it was self-evident that it was in direct contradiction to the teachings of the Nonviolent Jesus of the Gospels.

 

Did isolated Christians and groups of Christians engage in defensive or retaliatory violence? Of course they did. But the Church never called it good or taught it as a way of faithful discipleship. Just as Christian committed adultery, but the Church never called it good or taught it as a way of faithful discipleship for those chosen by Jesus to be among his followers. “Nevertheless,” was not in the vocabulary of Christian moral discourse and discernment in original Christianity or for the first three hundred years thereafter. Yet, today “Nevertheless” is the operating moral norm in almost all Churches. “Nevertheless” owes its place in Christianity to the Fourth Century theologians and writers Ambrose and Augustine—not Jesus.

 

—Emmanuel Charles McCarthy

 

All FAST FOOD Helpings are available at this URL:

http://centerforchristiannonviolence.org/events/fast-food-2018.

 

admin
Previous post FAST FOOD (2018): Seventh Helping Next post FAST FOOD (2018): Fifth Helping

Recent Posts

  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Fortieth Helping
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Thirty-Ninth Helping
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Thirty-Eighth Helping
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Thirty-Seventh Helping
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Thirty-Sixth Helping

Recent Comments

  • admin on Fast Food 2022 1st Jul to 9th Aug (40th Anniversary)
  • Patrick on Fast Food 2022 1st Jul to 9th Aug (40th Anniversary)
  • Elbon Kilpatrick on First Homily by Fr. McCarthy – September 13, 1981
  • Sally Gould on First Homily by Fr. McCarthy – September 13, 1981
  • Jan J Wnekn on First Homily by Fr. McCarthy – September 13, 1981

Recent Posts

  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Fortieth Helping August 10, 2023
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Thirty-Ninth Helping August 8, 2023
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Thirty-Eighth Helping August 7, 2023
  • FAST FOOD (AD 2023): Thirty-Seventh Helping August 6, 2023
October 2023
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031  
« Aug    

Tags

A Christian Response to Terrorism August 9 The Censer Behold the lamb capital punishment christian nonviolence christians in the military Christmas civil disobedience Collection for the Catholic Military Archdiocese Death electing a pope Emmanuel Charles charlie McCarthy Emmanuel Charles McCarthy emmanuel mccarthy fast food Fasting Gospel Gospel nonviolence jesus journal kingdom of the lamb Love your enemies Meaning Mercy Mercy:The essence of the Gospel Mercy and the Gospel military chaplain Nonviolence Nonviolent Jesus Nonviolent Mercy Nonviolent Way oath pope's final day pope benedict's resignation pope resigns pope resigns 2013 prayer prayer for peace Resurrection spanish swearing The Lamb Rich in Mercy vocations Vocations and prayer issues when a pope resigns zabelka

Categories

  • 'Special Topics (10)
  • Action Against Violence (13)
  • Audio Files (11)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2012 (42)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2014 (40)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2016 (42)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2018 (40)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2019 (40)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2020 (1)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2013 (40)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2015 (40)
  • Booklets (11)
  • Books (5)
  • Edith Stein (6)
  • Fast Food Helpings (Previous) (199)
    • Blog – Fast Food 2022 (1)
  • Home (8)
  • Images of War (16)
  • Jesus Journal (8)
  • Other Resources (194)
    • Blog – Fast Food 2023 (40)
  • Retreats (3)
  • Special topics (64)
  • The Nonviolent Eucharist (5)
  • Transcripts (10)
  • Uncategorized (36)
  • Videos (17)
  • Vocations and Prayer Articles (26)

About Us

The full embracing of Gospel Nonviolence calls for a radical alteration in thought patterns, verbal patterns, behavioral patterns, and emotional patterns. That is, it requires a completely different reality orientation and self-understanding.

Quick Links

  • Faq’s
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Terms & Conditions

Contacts

8 Moneynoe Park Enniskillen , Co. Fermanagh Northern Ireland, BT74 4ER
Facebook
Vimeo
Behance
Instagram
Xing
SoundCloud
Copyright © 2021 All Rights Reserved by Fr. Emmanuel Charles McCarthy