Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Instagram
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Books
  • Retreats
  • Interviews
  • Resources
  • Reflections
  • Other Resources
  • Donate
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
Product was added to your cart

Cart

FAST FOOD (2014): Eighteenth Helping

July 19, 2014adminBlog - Fast Food 2014, Fast Food Helpings (Previous)

Again, “We adore God Who is love, who in Jesus Christ gave Himself for us, Who offered Himself on the Cross to expiate our sins, and through the power of this love, rose from the dead and lives in His Church. We have no God other than Him” (Pope Francis, 6/21/14).

It is well pass the time for the proponents of justified violence to stop asserting that their choice of violence is “only reasonable.” It is equally pass time for the advocates of nonviolence to stop saying that bringing violence into the human situation is always unreasonable. Violence is unreasonable, but so is nonviolence. Both positions can be defended or repudiate with impeccable logic. There is no unassailable logical argument for the intrinsic immorality of employing violence, per se, in the human situation. But neither is there an unassailable logical argument for the use of violence within the mystery of human existence. Any reasonable argument forbidding the use of violence, per se, among humans can be countered by an equally reasonable argument for permitting the use of violence, per se, among humans. Reason alone cannot validate whether it is intrinsically good to introduce violence, pre se, against others human being into the human condition or whether it is always intrinsically evil.

(A parenthetical note may be appropriate here. Nonviolence means no violence. The person who maintains, “I am nonviolent but…” then presents a situation where he or she would use violence is not nonviolent, but is rather someone who believes it right to introduce violence into human situation.)

Since the decision to be an agent to introduce violence into the mystery of human existence can never be a decision based on incontestable reasonableness, what is the ultimate basis on which one thinks it is right to choose to be a channel for letting violence enter into the world of human relationships? Faith! The decision that it is right and proper to become an agent for the power of violence to become part of the human condition is not and cannot be a logical decision. In this area what logic propose as truth , logic can dispose of as truth. The mystery of a single human existence, let alone the mystery of the existence of all humanity—past, present and future— and the mystery of existence itself, is too immense to logically calculate with any integrity whether violence should be part of the atmosphere between and among human beings or not.

One’s position on whether human violence against other humans is good, right and proper or whether it is never good, right and proper is not a position within the purview of determination by reason. So it is imperative to stop the talk that violence is reasonable or that non-violence is reasonable. Neither can be a reasonable choice. Both are faith choices. After the basic faith choice is made, then implementation of it is a matter that is within the domain of determination by logic and reasonableness. For example, determining whether a person can carry ten or thirty stones to defend himself or can have 50 or 2000 nuclear weapons to defend herself, these are issues open to logical determination after the faith decision is made that violence belongs in the human situation. And, such is also precisely the necessary case with nonviolence.

After the faith decision has been made that violence is not to be part of the human situation and I therefore must not be its agent into humanity, I still have to figure out how to implement that faith stance, and it will be by logic and reason that I will figure that out. But, the primal decision of whether to bring violence or never to bring violence into the state of being human beings is beyond reason’s capacities to decide. It is and always has been a faith decision. The search for truth necessitates that we name violence and nonviolence what they are—faith choices—and get on with discerning truthfully what the faith is that we really hold and hold tight to.

-Emmanuel Charles McCarthy (To be continued)

admin
Previous post FAST FOOD (2014): Seventeenth Helping Next post FAST FOOD (2014): Nineteenth Helping

Recent Posts

  • AUGUST 9 by Fr Emmanuel Charles McCarthy
  • First Homily by Fr. McCarthy – September 13, 1981
  • Mao and Jesus – Part VII
  • Mao and Jesus – Part VI
  • Mao and Jesus – Part V

Recent Comments

  • Elbon Kilpatrick on First Homily by Fr. McCarthy – September 13, 1981
  • Sally Gould on First Homily by Fr. McCarthy – September 13, 1981

Recent Posts

  • AUGUST 9 by Fr Emmanuel Charles McCarthy August 15, 2021
  • First Homily by Fr. McCarthy – September 13, 1981 August 9, 2021
  • Mao and Jesus – Part VII March 15, 2021
  • Mao and Jesus – Part VI March 15, 2021
May 2022
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031  
« Aug    

Tags

A Christian Response to Terrorism August 9 The Censer Behold the lamb capital punishment christian nonviolence christians in the military Christmas civil disobedience Collection for the Catholic Military Archdiocese Death electing a pope Emmanuel Charles charlie McCarthy Emmanuel Charles McCarthy emmanuel mccarthy fast food Fasting Gospel Gospel nonviolence jesus journal kingdom of the lamb Love your enemies Meaning Mercy Mercy:The essence of the Gospel Mercy and the Gospel military chaplain Nonviolence Nonviolent Jesus Nonviolent Mercy Nonviolent Way oath pope's final day pope benedict's resignation pope resigns pope resigns 2013 prayer prayer for peace Resurrection spanish swearing The Lamb Rich in Mercy vocations Vocations and prayer issues when a pope resigns zabelka

Categories

  • 'Special Topics (4)
  • Action Against Violence (12)
  • Audio Files (11)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2012 (42)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2014 (40)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2016 (42)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2018 (40)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2019 (40)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2020 (1)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2013 (40)
  • Blog – Fast Food 2015 (40)
  • Booklets (10)
  • Books (4)
  • Edith Stein (6)
  • Fast Food Helpings (Previous) (198)
  • Home (7)
  • Images of War (16)
  • Jesus Journal (8)
  • Other Resources (151)
  • Retreats (3)
  • Special topics (56)
  • The Nonviolent Eucharist (5)
  • Transcripts (10)
  • Uncategorized (36)
  • Videos (17)
  • Vocations and Prayer Articles (26)

About Us

The full embracing of Gospel Nonviolence calls for a radical alteration in thought patterns, verbal patterns, behavioral patterns, and emotional patterns. That is, it requires a completely different reality orientation and self-understanding.

Quick Links

  • Faq’s
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Terms & Conditions

Contacts

8 Moneynoe Park Enniskillen , Co. Fermanagh Northern Ireland, BT74 4ER
Facebook
Vimeo
Behance
Instagram
Xing
SoundCloud
Copyright © 2021 All Rights Reserved by Fr. Emmanuel Charles McCarthy